There are chocolate bunnies at Easter, and candy hearts for Valentine’s Day, but there is no candy more closely associated with a holiday than candy corn and Halloween. This delightful confection was first invented in the 1880’s, and was an immediate hit. Farmers, especially, seemed to be fond of the kernel-shaped candy. Today, nearly 8.3 BILLION pieces of candy corn are produced each year, and most are sold between September and November. We thought it might be fun to try making our own version of this Halloween treat, so, here is the recipe and instructions.
Ingredients and Utensils
1/4 cup white cane sugar, not powdered
2 tbsp light corn syrup
1 tbsp honey
1 tbsp butter
1/4 tsp vanilla extract
5/8 cup powdered sugar.
1/16 tsp salt- just fill up an 1/8 tsp halfway
1 tbsp powdered milk
food colours: red and yellow for traditionnal candy corn, or any colours you like.
Note on Ingredients:
If you do not have a candy thermometer, get one. A regular thermometer doesn’t work at 250F and drop testing the sugar tends to be rather imprecise.
The powdered sugar needs to be powdered, not granulated. If it isn’t, you will have a large, delicious, but sticky, mess.
The salt can be omitted, as it has a minimal effect on the taste.
You MUST use powdered milk, not liquid.
This recipe may be doubled without affecting the consistency of the finished product.
Directions
Following these steps correctly will determine whether you will have a soft, honey-and-milk candy or a solid mass that is impossible to cut.
First: Make sure there is enough water in the botton of the pot to cover it entirely. Without some water, your sugar will burn.
Then: Measure your cane sugar, corn syrup, honey, butter, and vanilla into the pot.
For measuring the butter, the paper wrapping should have tablespoons marked on it, so cut it there, or just scoop it with the spoon.
Now that all your ingredients are together, stir them together a bit. This should result in a bit of a slush. Clip on the candy thermometer and put it on the stove.
Next: Cook over medium-high heat. The slush will become liquid quickly, so stir frequently and check the temperature constantly. If you smell burning or see any darker colouring, turn the heat down, stir a whole lot, and hope the sugar’s still fine. The mixture will bubble a lot. This is normal. The color should be a very light caramel.
It takes about 3 minutes for the sugar to reach 250F, but dont’t rely on the time. Watch the thermometer closely as the temperature rises. As soon as it reaches 250F (not 250C) turn the stove off.
Making dough
Using a flour sifter, sift the following ingredients into your sugar mixture:
1tbsp powdered milk
1/2 cup + 2tbsp powdered sugar
pinch of salt
Stir until you have an even consistency without clumps. You will have a pale caramel dough.
Pour about 1/4 cup powdered sugar into a bowl. With a wooden spoon, scrape the dough off the pot and into the bowl. coat the top of the dough with a thin layer of powdered sugar. If the dough isn’t burning to the touch, knead it until it is firm enough to form into balls, one for each color you want to use for your candy corn.
Coloring and rolling
Poke a hole in each ball and squeeze a few drops ( 3 or 4) into the hole. Now, knead the dough until the colouring is evenly distributed ( or nicely marbled.) You may want to use plastic gloves to avoid coloring your hands as well.
Once you have your colored balls of dough, start rolling them out in your hands until you have a long rope of candy. Lay the 3 colored ropes together in whatever order you want, and push them together until they stick to each other. Stretch and flatten the rope until it is about an inch wide and about 1/2 inch thick.
Cutting and Finishing
Cutting the ropes into candy-corn sized pieces with a medium, non-serrated knife.
Every other piece will have a white tip. If you want them all to have white tips, experiment with a bull’s eye formation for cutting (small circle of white, surrounded by ropes of orange and yellow). To ensure that it won’t stick to the sheet, move the pieces around on the sheet. Let them sit there overnight to lose a bit of moisture and harden a bit.
Congratulations!
You now have homemade candy corn! You will find that you have produced a softer candy than what is commercially available, but the fresh taste will more than make up for the difference.